SteinBlog

The Trouble with Physics

I do not normally recommend books that I read to a wider public. Partly because I’m disappointed if someone dislikes a book that I loved, partly because I do not think that my taste is of interest to anyone, partly because 90% of my reading was written by Terry Pratchett. In addition, when it comes to Science books, I rarely finish any of them, partly because I don’t understand them, partly because they bore me to death.

But this one was different and since this is a blog partly concerned with science in general, I would like to recommend to you “The Trouble with Physics” by Lee Smolin. The book’s subtitle is “The rise of String Theory, the Fall of a Science, and What Comes Next”. You, likely to be a member of some molecular informatics community, may ask, who cares about String Theory, and you may be right at a first glance. This book, however, is about Science in general, the mechanisms that drive it, and about what can go wrong. It is as much a book about science, physics and string theory as it is about the people in science and how they shape the fate of their field and more importantly of the rest of the pack working in it. It if fascinating to follow Smolin’s account of the rise of String Theory as one of the leading theories in physics. It is frightening to realize that 20 years or more of String theory has, if we believe the book, not lead to a single, novel, unique prediction that has been verified afterwards by experiment.

But while the account of the rise of String Theory was very entertaining and informative to read, the rest of the book, dealing with questions of the alternative theories, of science sociology, what science really is and what we can do to keep a finite possibility of fundamental revolutions, is even better.

I’m going to stop here because I feel that this book, once you’ve started reading it, will speak for itself.


Categorised as: Hot Science, Life of Chris, Open Science, People, Scientific Culture, Teaching


2 Comments

  1. String theory is interesting. At some point, we’ll be calculating molecular properties based on string theory 🙂 It’s the moment that we realize that quantum tunneling was just the beginning of the new types of chemistry involved in sustainable life… btw, did you see that statement that a sugar tunneled?!? And I am still convincing my fellow bioinformaticians about tunneling of hydrogens in bioreactions 😉

  2. Yes, right.
    And did you know, the whole brain was actually a quantum computer. To prove that, you just need to talk fast and bombard your audience with the most recent but unrelated buzz words from as many fields of modern science as possible:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aw9Jo5qNCsQ

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *